Does Islam have to be political?
Islam's relationship with politics is a complex topic that varies among scholars and traditions. The Qur'an emphasizes the importance of justice, community welfare, and the establishment of a society based on moral principles, which can inherently lead to political engagement.
In Surah Al-Baqara, it is stated: And fight them until persecution is no more, and religion is for Allah. But if they desist, then let there be no hostility except against wrong-doers.
2:193 This verse indicates that while there may be circumstances where fighting is permissible, the overarching goal is to establish a society where worship is directed solely to Allah, suggesting that Islam has a political dimension aimed at establishing justice and preventing oppression.
Tafsir Ibn Kathir explains that this concept is supported by prophetic teachings that advocate for retaliation to match the harm received but prohibits excess. He emphasizes that the ultimate aim is to eradicate disbelief and allow God's religion to prevail, reinforcing the necessity of political action in certain contexts to fulfill these objectives.
Moreover, the hadith literature informs us about the Prophet Muhammad's ﷺ approach to governance and community leadership. For instance, in Al-Kafi, it mentions that Islam is built upon five pillars: prayer, almsgiving, fasting, pilgrimage, and allegiance (wilayah). Nothing was called out for like allegiance.
Al-Kafi 1:42 This underscores the importance of political allegiance and governance in the practice of Islam.
In conclusion, while the extent to which Islam is political may differ among various interpretations, the foundational teachings of the Qur'an and the Sunnah highlight the significance of justice, community welfare, and moral governance as essential aspects that can lead to a political dimension in Islam.
Sources
-
2:193 · Al-Baqara
2:193 · Muhammad Marmaduke Pickthall
وَقَٰتِلُوهُمْ حَتَّىٰ لَا تَكُونَ فِتْنَةٌۭ وَيَكُونَ ٱلدِّينُ لِلَّهِ ۖ فَإِنِ ٱنتَهَوْا۟ فَلَا عُدْوَٰنَ إِلَّا عَلَى ٱلظَّٰلِمِينَ
And fight them until persecution is no more, and religion is for Allah. But if they desist, then let there be no hostility except against wrong-doers.
-
Tafsir Ibn Kathir on 2:193
Tafsir Ibn Kathir · 2:193
Abu Ja'far Al-Razi reported from Al-Rabee' ibn Anas, from Abu Al-Aliyyah, regarding the phrase "And fight in the cause of Allah those who fight you" (Qur'an 2:193), that this was the first verse revealed in Medina referring to fighting. When it was revealed, the Messenger of Allah ﷺ fought only those who fought him and refrained from fighting those who refrained until the revelation of Surah Bara'ah. Similarly, Abd al-Rahman ibn Zaid ibn Aslam said this verse was abrogated by the command to "kill the polytheists wherever you find them" (Qur'an 9:5). However, this is subject to interpretation, because the phrase "those who fight you" seems to incite the enemies who intended to fight Islam and its people to be fought back similarly. As stated elsewhere, "And fight the polytheists all together as they fight you all together" (9:36). Therefore, in this verse it is said, "kill them wherever you catch them and expel them from where they expelled you," urging equal resolve in combat, as their resolve is towards fighting you and expelling you from your lands—the punishment corresponds. It has also been narrated from Abu Bakr Al-Siddiq, may Allah be pleased with him, that the first verse revealed concerning fighting after the Hijra was "Permission to fight is granted to those who are being fought" (Qur'an 22:39), which is the more widely known view and supported by accompanying hadith. Regarding the phrase "And do not transgress; indeed, Allah does not like transgressors," Ibn Kathir explains that this means fighting in Allah's cause must be limited and not exceed the boundaries, including avoiding forbidden acts such as mutilation, betrayal, killing women, children, elders without fighting capability, monks, burning trees, or killing beasts without necessity. This interpretation is affirmed by prominent authorities such as Al-Hasan Al-Basri, Ibn Abbas, Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz, and Muqatil ibn Hayyan. In Sahih Muslim, Buraidah reports that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said, "March forth in Allah's cause, fight those who disbelieve in Allah, but do not betray, do not mutilate, do not commit treachery, do not kill children or monks in monasteries." Imam Ahmad, Ibn Abbas, and Abu Dawud narrated similar reports. Ibn Umar recounted that he saw a woman killed during some of the Prophet’s battles, and the Prophet disapproved of killing women and children. Imam Ahmad related from Hudhayfah the Prophet’s example of battles where weaker people were oppressed by stronger and hostile parties, and then used improperly as tools, thus angering Allah upon them until the Day they meet Him. This hadith is considered sound and highlights misuse of power and unjust aggression. Since jihad involves taking lives and intense fighting, Allah warns that what the disbelievers embrace — disbelief, polytheism, and blocking the path of Allah — are graver and more harmful than killing itself. Hence the statement, "And fitnah (persecution, trial) is worse than killing," indicating that perseverance in disbelief is a worse affliction than death. Many scholars including Abu Al-Aliyah, Mujahid, Sa'id ibn Jubayr, Ikrimah, Al-Hasan, Qatadah, Al-Dahhak, and Al-Rabee' ibn Anas interpret "fitnah is worse than killing" to specifically mean that associating partners with Allah (polytheism) is a greater calamity than killing. The prohibition against fighting near the Sacred Mosque is reinforced by authentic hadith, stating that this land was sanctified by Allah since creation, and fighting there is forbidden except for a brief time allowed to the Prophet ﷺ during the conquest of Mecca. Fighting then was directed at its inhabitants upon their hostility, but thereafter fighting in the sanctuary is forbidden. Those who permitted fighting near the Sacred Mosque during the Prophet’s time were unauthorized, as Allah only permitted the Messenger. Al-Qurtubi narrates that the prohibition of fighting near the Sacred Mosque was abrogated by verses commanding attacking the polytheists after the sacred months have passed. Qatadah and Muqatil ibn Hayyan provide differing views, but the dominant understanding is that the initial prohibition was abrogated. The instruction to fight them until they fight you in the Sacred Mosque means that one should not initiate combat there. However, if they begin fighting, then fighting them is permitted as a defensive measure. This is exemplified by the Prophet’s pledge to his companions at Al-Hudaybiyyah to fight the assembled forces wishing to attack them. Later Allah stopped the fighting between them after the Muslims' victory. If the enemies cease fighting in the sanctuary and return to Islam or repentance, Allah is forgiving and merciful toward them, even if they had previously killed Muslims within the sacred precincts. This reflects Allah’s readiness to forgive those who sincerely repent. The command to fight the disbelievers continues until no fitnah (i.e., polytheism and persecution) remains and religion belongs solely to Allah—meaning Islam becomes supreme over other faiths. This is supported by statements of Ibn Abbas and other scholars. The Prophet ﷺ said that whoever fights so that the word of Allah is exalted is truly fighting in Allah’s cause. Muslims were commanded to fight until people say "There is no god but Allah," after which their blood and property are protected except by just cause, and Allah will judge them. The verse concludes saying if they desist, there is no aggression except against oppressors. This is interpreted to mean that fighting is only permitted against those who initiate aggression. Whoever stops has freed himself from the sin of oppression, which is tantamount to disbelief and injustice. This concept is reiterated in prophetic sayings and Qur'anic verses urging retaliation to resemble the harm inflicted but prohibiting excess. Al-Bukhari related from Ibn Umar that when two men urged him to join in fighting during the time of the civil strife of Ibn Az-Zubair, he refused saying that the killing of his brother was prohibited by Allah. He explained that they had fought until there was no fitnah and religion was for Allah, while they intended to fight until fitnah existed and religion was for others. Ibn Umar further explained the pillars of Islam—faith, prayer, fasting Ramadan, giving zakat, and pilgrimage—and emphasized abiding by the Prophet's covenant not to fight unjustly. In summary, this verse establishes the principle of defensive fighting permitted only against those who initiate hostilities, with strict prohibitions against transgressing limits. The ultimate goal is to eradicate disbelief and polytheism so that God's religion alone prevails, while mercy is extended to repentant enemies.
-
Al-Kafi 1:42
Al-Kafi · Book 1, Hadith 42
Islam is built upon five pillars: prayer, almsgiving, fasting, pilgrimage, and allegiance (wilayah). Nothing was called out for like allegiance. — OR — I asked Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) about a jar in which a beetle has died. He said: Throw it out and perform ablution from the water. If it was a scorpion, then stir the water and perform ablution with water from elsewhere. Regarding a man who has two vessels with water, and dirt falls into one and he is unsure which, and cannot obtain water from another source, he said: Mix them both and perform tayammum. — OR — The Messenger of God (peace be upon him and his family) said: The believer eats according to the desire of his family, while the hypocrite's family eats according to his own desire. — OR — If a people besieged a city and asked for security and were refused, then thought that they had been given it and approached the city, they would indeed be safe. — OR — No man whose wife is pregnant and who intends to name the child Muhammad will fail to have a male child, God willing. Here he stated three (examples), all named Muhammad. Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) also said in another narration that at the four months he would take the woman’s hand, face the Qibla and say, 'O God, I have named him Muhammad, a boy was born to her, and if he changes the name, he will be taken away.' — OR — Regarding a man who made a will and his heirs approved it, but after his death they revoked the will, do they have the right to annul what they had accepted? He said, 'They do not have that right. The will is valid if they accepted it during his lifetime.' — OR — Ali ibn Ibrahim narrated from his father from Muhammad ibn Sulayman from al-Fadl ibn Isma'il al-Hashimi from his father: I complained to Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) about the neglect toward religion by some of my household. He said, "O Isma'il, do not be surprised at that from your household, for indeed God, blessed and exalted, appoints for every household a proof (hujjah) by which he will argue against his own household on the Day of Resurrection. It will be said to them: Didn't you see so-and-so among you? Didn't you see his guidance among you? Did you not see his prayer among you? Did you not see his religion among you? Why then did you not follow him? So he will be a proof against them on the Day of Resurrection."
Answers are generated and checked automatically; they may still be incomplete or imperfect. For religious rulings, consult a qualified scholar.
Ask your own question →