Eating garlic before visiting the masjid - ambiguous hadith
The topic of eating garlic before visiting the mosque is addressed in several hadith that discuss its odor and the etiquette surrounding entering places of worship. The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ advised against approaching the mosque after consuming garlic due to its strong smell, which could disturb others.
One narration from Al-Kafi states: I asked him about eating garlic. He said: The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him and his family) forbade it because of its smell. He said: Whoever eats this loathsome plant should not approach our mosque. But whoever eats it and does not come to the mosque, no harm is upon him.
Al-Kafi 6:762. This indicates that while garlic is discouraged before entering the mosque, there is no sin for those who consume it and do not attend the mosque afterward.
Additionally, another narration clarifies: I was asked about eating garlic, onions and leeks. He said: There is no harm in eating them raw or cooked, and no harm in using garlic as medicine. But if one eats any of these, he should not go to the mosque.
Al-Kafi 6:763. This suggests that while the consumption of these vegetables is permissible, care should be taken in communal settings like the mosque where the scent might be bothersome to others.
Thus, while there is a clear guideline about avoiding garlic before visiting the mosque, it does not carry a penalty if one consumes it and does not attend the mosque. The emphasis is on maintaining respect for the space and consideration for fellow worshippers.
Sources
-
Al-Kafi 6:762
Al-Kafi · Book 6, Hadith 762 · Narrated by Abu Ja'far (peace be upon him)
I asked him about eating garlic. He said: The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him and his family) forbade it because of its smell. He said: Whoever eats this loathsome plant should not approach our mosque. But whoever eats it and does not come to the mosque, no harm is upon him.
-
Al-Kafi 6:763
Al-Kafi · Book 6, Hadith 763 · Narrated by Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him)
I was asked about eating garlic, onions and leeks. He said: There is no harm in eating them raw or cooked, and no harm in using garlic as medicine. But if one eats any of these, he should not go to the mosque.
Answers are generated and checked automatically; they may still be incomplete or imperfect. For religious rulings, consult a qualified scholar.
Ask your own question →