← Back to questions

Is downloading educational videos through torrents haram if they are ordinarily viewable online?

The question of whether downloading educational videos through torrents, especially those that are ordinarily viewable online, is considered haram involves the principles of lawful and unlawful consumption of wealth as taught in Islamic teachings.

According to Sunni scholarship, Tafsir Ibn Kathir discusses the importance of not unlawfully consuming the wealth of others. It notes that Allah prohibits His believers from gaining wealth through illegitimate means such as usury and deceit. The verse states: Whoso doeth that through aggression and injustice, we shall cast him into Fire, and that is ever easy for Allah. 4:30 This implies that actions taken to acquire something unlawfully—even if it is educational content—could lead to severe consequences if they involve injustice or aggression towards the rights of others.

From the Shia perspective, Majma al-Bayan similarly emphasizes the importance of lawful means in acquiring wealth and resources. The teachings encourage believers to engage only in transactions that are mutually agreed upon and fair, reflecting the necessity of ethical conduct in all forms of consumption, including digital content.

While it may be argued that downloading educational videos for personal use could be perceived as harmless, the act of doing so through torrents—often associated with piracy—can infringe on the rights of content creators and violate copyright laws. This would fall under the broader prohibition of unjustly consuming another's wealth, as it could be seen as taking something that is not rightfully yours.

In conclusion, both Sunni and Shia scholarship advises against actions that involve unjust acquisition of resources. Thus, if downloading educational videos through torrents is considered a violation of the rights of the content creators, it would be deemed haram. For specific rulings that apply to individual situations, it is always best to consult a qualified local scholar.

Sources

Answers are generated and checked automatically; they may still be incomplete or imperfect. For religious rulings, consult a qualified scholar.

Ask your own question →