Is downloading educational videos through torrents haram if they are ordinarily viewable online?
The question of whether downloading educational videos through torrents, especially those that are ordinarily viewable online, is considered haram involves the principles of lawful and unlawful consumption of wealth as taught in Islamic teachings.
According to Sunni scholarship, Tafsir Ibn Kathir discusses the importance of not unlawfully consuming the wealth of others. It notes that Allah prohibits His believers from gaining wealth through illegitimate means such as usury and deceit. The verse states: Whoso doeth that through aggression and injustice, we shall cast him into Fire, and that is ever easy for Allah.
4:30 This implies that actions taken to acquire something unlawfully—even if it is educational content—could lead to severe consequences if they involve injustice or aggression towards the rights of others.
From the Shia perspective, Majma al-Bayan similarly emphasizes the importance of lawful means in acquiring wealth and resources. The teachings encourage believers to engage only in transactions that are mutually agreed upon and fair, reflecting the necessity of ethical conduct in all forms of consumption, including digital content.
While it may be argued that downloading educational videos for personal use could be perceived as harmless, the act of doing so through torrents—often associated with piracy—can infringe on the rights of content creators and violate copyright laws. This would fall under the broader prohibition of unjustly consuming another's wealth, as it could be seen as taking something that is not rightfully yours.
In conclusion, both Sunni and Shia scholarship advises against actions that involve unjust acquisition of resources. Thus, if downloading educational videos through torrents is considered a violation of the rights of the content creators, it would be deemed haram. For specific rulings that apply to individual situations, it is always best to consult a qualified local scholar.
Sources
-
4:30 · An-Nisaa
4:30 · Muhammad Marmaduke Pickthall
وَمَن يَفْعَلْ ذَٰلِكَ عُدْوَٰنًۭا وَظُلْمًۭا فَسَوْفَ نُصْلِيهِ نَارًۭا ۚ وَكَانَ ذَٰلِكَ عَلَى ٱللَّهِ يَسِيرًا
Whoso doeth that through aggression and injustice, we shall cast him into Fire, and that is ever easy for Allah.
-
Tafsir Ibn Kathir on 4:30
Tafsir Ibn Kathir · 4:30
Allah, the Glorified and Exalted, forbids His believing servants from unlawfully consuming the wealth of others, meaning gaining wealth through illegitimate means such as usury (riba), gambling, and all deceitful tricks that resemble these forbidden gains. Ibn Jarir narrated from Ibn Abbas about a man buying a garment with the agreement that if satisfied he would keep it and if not, return it with a dirham; Ibn Abbas said this is what Allah referred to in the verse "And do not consume one another's wealth unjustly." This demonstrates that only mutually agreed trade is lawful. Ibn Abi Hatim narrated that the verse "O you who believe, do not consume one another's wealth unjustly" is a firm, un-abrogated command that remains valid until the Day of Resurrection. Ali ibn Abi Talha reported from Ibn Abbas that when this verse was revealed, Muslims expressed concern that since food is the best wealth, eating at another’s home seemed forbidden, prompting the revelation of the subsequent verse "No blame upon the blind..." (Qur'an 24:61) to allow concession in such cases. The phrase "except it be trade by mutual consent" is a permissive exception, indicating that legitimate, consensual business transactions are allowed and encouraged to acquire wealth. This was used by Imam Shafi'i to argue that sale requires consent, as the text explicitly mentions mutual agreement, contrasting with unilateral gifts which may not necessarily imply consent. However, Maliki, Hanafi, Ahmad, and their followers disagreed, permitting certain sales even without explicit oral consent, if inferred from actions, especially in minor transactions. Mujahid interpreted "trade by mutual consent" as either a sale or a gift freely given between two parties. The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ said, according to a report by Maimun ibn Mihran, "Sales are conducted by mutual consent; the buyer and seller have a right to rescind the sale before they part. It is not lawful for a Muslim to deceive another Muslim." This hadith emphasizes the importance of mutual consent and honesty in transactions. Another key point is the doctrine of the option to rescind a sale (khiyar al-majlis), validated by the Prophet's saying, "The two buyers/sellers have the option to rescind as long as they remain together." This principle was upheld by Shafi'i, Ahmad ibn Hanbal, and most early and later scholars. Similarly, the right of option due to a stipulated condition (khiyar al-shart) is accepted up to three days or more depending on the nature of the subject matter. The verse continues with the prohibition "And do not kill yourselves," which is interpreted broadly to include avoiding all acts that cause harm to oneself, such as committing major sins and unlawfully consuming each other's wealth. Allah's mercy is present in His commands and prohibitions. A hadith related by Amr ibn al-As shows his concern about performing ablution in extreme cold and his reliance on the allowance of tayammum (dry ablution) based on this verse. The Prophet ﷺ smiled but did not reprimand him, indicating that Allah’s mercy permits concessions. Other hadith warn against suicide, stating that whoever kills himself with a sharp object will hold that object on the Day of Judgment as punishment in Hell forever. The phrase "whoever does that in aggression and injustice," refers to one who knowingly and defiantly disobeys Allah's prohibitions, which is a grave sin warranting severe punishment. The verse then promises: "If you avoid the major sins which you are forbidden, We will absolve your minor sins and admit you to a noble entrance (Paradise)." This means that avoiding major sins leads to forgiveness of lesser sins and entry into Paradise. Scholars have narrated many hadith enumerating the major sins, usually seven, including shirk (associating partners with Allah), killing without right, magic, usury, consuming the wealth of orphans unjustly, fleeing the battlefield, and slandering chaste women. Other lists add the violation of family ties, lying in testimony, drinking alcohol, and more. The companions and followers discussed the scope of major sins, some considering any sin carrying a severe warning or punishment as major. Ibn Abbas stated the number of major sins is more than seven, possibly up to seventy, and that no sin is major if sincere repentance and forgiveness are possible. The overall guidance of this verse and its commentary is a strong prohibition on unjust and unlawful consumption of others' wealth, paired with a command to avoid major sins, with the promise of mercy and forgiveness from Allah for those who do so. It underlines the importance of fairness, mutual consent in transactions, respect for life, refraining from sin, and the hope of Allah’s reward upon sincere avoidance of serious wrongdoings.
-
Majma al-Bayan fi Tafsir al-Qur'an on 4:30
Majma al-Bayan fi Tafsir al-Qur'an · 4:30
Recitation Variants: The people of Kufa read the phrase as an accusative (تجارة), while others read it in the nominative. The Grammatical Argument: Abu Ali said that those who read it in the nominative understand it as: "except that a trade occur," which results in a disconnected exception clause because trading done by mutual consent does not constitute unlawful gain. For those who read it as accusative, two interpretations are possible: first, it could mean "except that the trade be a trade by mutual consent," similar to the poetic usage "If the day is a day of stars," meaning "if the day is a certain day." Second, it could mean that the word "trade" is missing its possessive adjunct (مضاف), implying that the money is money from trade, so the omission is filled by context. Thus, in both cases, the exception is not continuous or complete. Meaning: After Allah forbade unlawful sexual relations, He immediately forbade unlawful consumption of wealth: "O you who have believed! Do not consume one another's wealth unjustly." The verb "consume" is mentioned but includes all forms of taking and transferring wealth because consuming often implies acquiring benefits, and even spending in various ways could be metaphorically called consuming wealth. The phrase "unjustly" (بالباطل) has two interpretations: one is unlawful gains such as usury, gambling, cheating, and oppression—this is from Al-Suddi, reported from Al-Baqir. The other is to take without rightful entitlement through other means—reported from Al-Hasan. A man would feel ashamed to take from someone once this verse was revealed, until it was abrogated by the verse in Surah Al-Nur regarding food from one's own homes. The first interpretation is stronger since what one gains through honorable means is not considered invalid consumption. Another interpretation says it means taking money without rightful cause and using it unlawfully. The exception "except that (تجارة) trade" means lawful sale or exchange done with mutual consent. There are two views about what "consent" means in commerce: one is that it validates the sale after initial offer and acceptance—a view held by Shurayh, Al-Sha'bi, Ibn Sirin, the Shafi'i, and Imami scholars—after which the buyer and seller have a period to annul the sale. The other is that consent is only through the contract itself, as held by Malik and Abu Hanifa. The phrase "do not kill yourselves" has four explanations: first, it means do not kill each other, because you belong to one faith and are like one soul, as in the verse "greet one another with peace"; this is reported by Al-Hasan, Ata, Al-Suddi, and Al-Jubay'i. Second, it is a prohibition of suicidal killing in a state of anger or distress, per Abu al-Qasim al-Balkhi. Third, it forbids self-destruction by committing sins and unlawful taking of wealth that would result in punishment. Fourth, Imam Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) said it means do not risk your lives in futile fighting against stronger enemies. "Indeed Allah has been to you Merciful" implies that Allah's mercy toward you has always existed, and by His mercy He forbade killing and corruption of wealth. "And whoever does that," said some, points back to unlawful consumption of wealth and unjust killing; others say it refers collectively to all prohibitions in the Surah starting from the beginning, including the prohibition against forcibly inheriting women. Some say it specifically refers to killing the sanctified soul. "Aggression and injustice" have been interpreted as synonymous words used to emphasize severity, much like the poet who said, "I find her speech to be lying and rampant falsehood." Some said aggression means exceeding God's command, and injustice is taking by unlawful means. Others interpret that the terms specify such acts are for those who deliberately make them permissible for themselves. "We will burn him in Fire" means Allah will make Fire burn him and punish him in it. "And that is easy for Allah" indicates that incineration and punishment in the Fire is easy for Him; nothing prevents it, nothing repels it, and no intercession is accepted except by His permission.
Answers are generated and checked automatically; they may still be incomplete or imperfect. For religious rulings, consult a qualified scholar.
Ask your own question →