Is it permissible to build a building taller than Kaaba around it?
According to Sunni scholarship, there are specific views regarding the construction of buildings taller than the Kaaba. A hadith in Sahih Muslim discusses a historical incident where Abdullah ibn al-Zubair, during the time of Yazid ibn Mu'awiya, faced a dispute regarding the rebuilding of the Kaaba after a fire. He stated, When the Kaaba caught fire during the time of Yazid ibn Mu'awiya, a dispute arose regarding its rebuilding. Abdullah ibn al-Zubair wanted to rebuild only what was damaged and leave the rest intact with the stones that the Prophet (ﷺ) had sent upon it. He said he sought guidance from God and was resolved on this course. After some opposition and people protesting, he proceeded to demolish the damaged parts. Then Ibn al-Zubair placed pillars and covered it with curtains until his building rose. He said he heard Aisha saying that the Prophet (ﷺ) said, 'If the people were not newly come to disbelief and I had money, I would have added five cubits of stone and made two doors for it to enter and exit from.' Ibn al-Zubair added five cubits more until its height surprised people. He built the Kaaba to eighteen cubits long. When it became shorter than usual, he extended its length by ten more cubits and made two doors, one for entering and one for exiting. When Ibn al-Zubair was killed, al-Hajjaj wrote to Abdul Malik ibn Marwan reporting this, and Abdul Malik approved the lengthening but restored the door to its original place and repudiated the rest.
Sahih Muslim 15:449. This narration indicates a historical precedent for modifications to the Kaaba's structure.
On the other hand, Shia scholarship, as reflected in Al-Kafi, presents a viewpoint regarding the sanctity of the Kaaba and its surroundings. It is narrated that it is not proper for a man to reside in Mecca for a full year. I asked: How should he act? He said: He should leave it. Also, no one should build a structure over the Ka’bah.
Al-Kafi 3:83. This indicates that Shia scholars generally discourage building structures that could overshadow or detract from the Kaaba's sanctity.
In summary, while Sunni tradition acknowledges modifications and rebuilding efforts, Shia tradition emphasizes the preservation of the Kaaba's sanctity and discourages building taller structures around it. For a ruling that applies to your specific situation, consult a qualified local scholar.
Sources
-
Sahih Muslim 15:449
Sahih Muslim · Book 15, Hadith 449 · Narrated by Ibn Abbas
When the Kaaba caught fire during the time of Yazid ibn Mu'awiya, a dispute arose regarding its rebuilding. Abdullah ibn al-Zubair wanted to rebuild only what was damaged and leave the rest intact with the stones that the Prophet (ﷺ) had sent upon it. He said he sought guidance from God and was resolved on this course. After some opposition and people protesting, he proceeded to demolish the damaged parts. Then Ibn al-Zubair placed pillars and covered it with curtains until his building rose. He said he heard Aisha saying that the Prophet (ﷺ) said, 'If the people were not newly come to disbelief and I had money, I would have added five cubits of stone and made two doors for it to enter and exit from.' Ibn al-Zubair added five cubits more until its height surprised people. He built the Kaaba to eighteen cubits long. When it became shorter than usual, he extended its length by ten more cubits and made two doors, one for entering and one for exiting. When Ibn al-Zubair was killed, al-Hajjaj wrote to Abdul Malik ibn Marwan reporting this, and Abdul Malik approved the lengthening but restored the door to its original place and repudiated the rest.
-
Al-Kafi 3:83
Al-Kafi · Book 3, Hadith 83
In describing the Ancient One (al-Qadim), he said: He is One, eternal, unique in meaning, not a multiplicity of diverse meanings. I said: "May I be your ransom! Some from the people of Iraq claim He hears without what perceives and sees without what hears." He said, "They have lied, deviated, and likened (Allah) to creation. Exalted be Allah above that! He is Hearing and Seeing; He hears by what He sees and sees by what He hears." I said, "They claim He sees only what they comprehend." He said, "Allah says, 'Only what is created can be comprehended,' and Allah is not such." — OR — Whoever believes in Allah and the Last Day should never omit reciting "Say: He is Allah, the One" after the obligatory prayers, for whoever recites it gathers for himself the best of this world and the Hereafter and his parents and children are forgiven. — OR — Regarding the verse of God Almighty: 'Why, when the soul reaches the throat (moment of death) ... if you are truthful,' he said, 'When the soul reaches the throat then he is shown his abode in Paradise and says, "Return me to the world so I may inform my family of what I see." He is told, "There is no way to do that."' — OR — It is not proper for a man to reside in Mecca for a full year. I asked: How should he act? He said: He should leave it. Also, no one should build a structure over the Ka’bah. It has been narrated that residing in Mecca hardens the hearts. — OR — Ali ibn Al-Husayn (peace be upon him), whenever his son-in-law or brother-in-law came to him regarding his daughter or sister, would extend his cloak over him, seat him, then say, 'Welcome to one who provides sustenance and shields the private parts.' — OR — I heard Abu Abdullah say: The Commander of the Faithful said: All people are free except those who acknowledge themselves as slaves knowingly, whether they were slaves when young or when old. — OR — I asked Abu Ja'far about a woman who married during her waiting period (‘iddah). He said: If she married during the waiting period of her husband’s divorce, then the ‘iddah remains on her and stoning applies. If she married during a waiting period without a husband’s divorce, then the punishment is that of an unmarried fornicatress. If she married during the waiting period after her husband’s death before the completion of four months and ten days, then no stoning applies but instead she is lashed one hundred times. I asked: What if that happened through ignorance? He said: Today among Muslim women there is no one unaware of the obligation of ‘iddah for divorce or death. The women of ignorance knew this. I asked: What if she knows that she has ‘iddah but does not know how long it is? He said: If she knows she has a waiting period, then she is obligated to inquire until she learns it.
Answers are generated and checked automatically; they may still be incomplete or imperfect. For religious rulings, consult a qualified scholar.
Ask your own question →