← Back to questions

Is it universally agreed which surahs are Meccan and which are Medinan? If so, when did this agreement arise?

The classification of surahs in the Qur'an as Meccan or Medinan is generally accepted among scholars, though there may be some differing opinions regarding specific surahs. This classification is significant because it often reflects the context and themes addressed in the revelations, with Meccan surahs typically focusing on foundational beliefs and spiritual matters, while Medinan surahs often address community laws and social issues.

The consensus regarding the classification of these surahs has developed over time, particularly from the early Islamic period through the work of scholars who compiled and analyzed the Qur'an's contents. The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) would receive revelations at varying times throughout his life, and the organization of the surahs was influenced by the Prophet's guidance.

A relevant hadith illustrates this process. Sunan Abu Dawud narrates that Uthman ibn Affan was asked about why he included Al-Bara'ah (At-Tawbah), which is among the Meccan chapters, and Al-Anfal, which is among the Medinan chapters, in the seven long surahs, without a bismillah line between them. He said: The Prophet (peace be upon him) would receive revelation and command those who wrote for him to place the verse where it concerned, and when a verse or verses arrived he instructed accordingly. Al-Anfal was among the earliest Medinan revelations and Al-Bara'ah one of the last in the Quran. Because their stories were related, I thought to include them among the seven long ones without adding a bismillah line between. The Prophet (peace be upon him) passed away without us being informed that these chapters were to be separated by bismillah Sunan Abu Dawud 2:396SunniDaif (per Al-Albani).

This indicates that the arrangement of the surahs was not arbitrary but rather based on the context of their revelations and their thematic connections. The classification as Meccan or Medinan has thus been solidified through scholarly work and historical accounts over the centuries following the Prophet's lifetime.

Sources

Answers are generated and checked automatically; they may still be incomplete or imperfect. For religious rulings, consult a qualified scholar.

Ask your own question →