Is raf` yadain mandatory in salah?
The question of whether raising the hands (raf` yadain) is mandatory in Salah (prayer) has differing views in Sunni and Shia traditions.
According to Sunni scholarship, as reflected in Tafsir Ibn Kathir, the action of raising the hands during prayer is supported by various hadiths. For example, Abdullah bin Umar reported: When Abdullah bin Umar was asked about the prayer during combat, he said: 'The imam leads a group of people praying one rak'ah, while another group, standing between them and the enemy, does not pray. After the imam completes one rak'ah, those who had prayed step back in the place of those who did not pray and do not say salam. Then those who had not prayed take their place to pray one rak'ah behind the imam. Then the imam completes two rak'ahs. Then each group prays two rak'ahs on their own after the imam has finished. If the danger is more severe, they stand as men, whether mounted or on foot, facing the Qiblah or not. Malik said: Nafi' said I do not see that Abdullah bin Umar narrated this except from the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ).
Sahih al-Bukhari 65:58 This indicates that the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ practiced raising the hands at the beginning of the prayer and when moving from one position to another, illustrating its importance in the prayer.
In contrast, Shia scholarship, as reflected in Majma al-Bayan, emphasizes that raising the hands is not obligatory. The Shia view aligns with the belief that while it is a recommended practice, it is not mandated. For instance, Imam al-Baqir and Imam al-Sadiq have explained that the essential components of prayer do not include raf` yadain as a requirement, focusing instead on the intention and the proper execution of the prayer's pillars.
This reflects a broader difference in practice, with Sunni scholars generally considering it a sunnah (recommended practice) and Shia scholars viewing it as optional rather than obligatory.
For a ruling that applies to your specific situation, consult a qualified local scholar.
Sources
-
Sahih al-Bukhari 65:58
Sahih al-Bukhari · Book 65, Hadith 58 · Narrated by Abdullah ibn Umar
When Abdullah bin Umar was asked about the prayer during combat, he said: 'The imam leads a group of people praying one rak'ah, while another group, standing between them and the enemy, does not pray. After the imam completes one rak'ah, those who had prayed step back in the place of those who did not pray and do not say salam. Then those who had not prayed take their place to pray one rak'ah behind the imam. Then the imam completes two rak'ahs. Then each group prays two rak'ahs on their own after the imam has finished. If the danger is more severe, they stand as men, whether mounted or on foot, facing the Qiblah or not. Malik said: Nafi' said I do not see that Abdullah bin Umar narrated this except from the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ).
Answers are generated and checked automatically; they may still be incomplete or imperfect. For religious rulings, consult a qualified scholar.
Ask your own question →