Why do some Muslim pray Zuhur/Asr silently while Allah in [Al-Quran:17:110] says to pray in a moderate tone?
The practice of praying silently during the Zuhur and Asr prayers is indeed related to the guidance given in the Qur'an, specifically in Surah Al-Israa. The verse states: Say (unto mankind): Cry unto Allah, or cry unto the Beneficent, unto whichsoever ye cry (it is the same). His are the most beautiful names. And thou (Muhammad), be not loud-voiced in thy worship nor yet silent therein, but follow a way between.
17:110. This verse instructs the believers to find a balance in their prayer recitation—neither too loud nor too quiet.
Ibn Kathir explains that this verse was revealed in Mecca while the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was praying aloud, and the disbelievers mocked him and the Qur'an upon hearing it. Thus, Allah instructed him to avoid loud recitation that could attract mockery while also ensuring that the companions could hear him. The directive is about maintaining a moderate tone in worship (Tafsir Ibn Kathir).
Supporting this interpretation, Ibn Abbas narrated: Regarding the verse 'Do not make your prayer loud, nor make it silent, but seek a way in between,' Ibn Abbas said: When the Prophet (peace be upon him) was concealed in Mecca, if he prayed with his companions, he recited loudly. Upon hearing that, the disbelievers mocked the Quran, its sender, and the one who brought it. So Allah revealed this command forbidding loud or silent prayer, but to select a middle way between loudness and quietness, so that his companions could hear but disbelievers would not be distressed by it.
Sahih Muslim 4:163.
Additionally, in Shia tradition, it is stated: I asked Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) whether the Imam should make those behind him hear the recitation, even if there are many. He said, 'He should recite middlingly, saying 'Allah, blessed and exalted is He,' and not recite loudly nor whisper.
Al-Kafi 4:219.
This balance is reflected in the practice of praying silently for the Zuhur and Asr prayers, allowing for a focus on the prayer without drawing attention or causing disturbance, thus following the guidance of maintaining moderation in worship as instructed in the Qur'an.
Sources
-
17:110 · Al-Israa
17:110 · Muhammad Marmaduke Pickthall
قُلِ ٱدْعُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ أَوِ ٱدْعُوا۟ ٱلرَّحْمَٰنَ ۖ أَيًّۭا مَّا تَدْعُوا۟ فَلَهُ ٱلْأَسْمَآءُ ٱلْحُسْنَىٰ ۚ وَلَا تَجْهَرْ بِصَلَاتِكَ وَلَا تُخَافِتْ بِهَا وَٱبْتَغِ بَيْنَ ذَٰلِكَ سَبِيلًۭا
Say (unto mankind): Cry unto Allah, or cry unto the Beneficent, unto whichsoever ye cry (it is the same). His are the most beautiful names. And thou (Muhammad), be not loud-voiced in thy worship nor yet silent therein, but follow a way between.
-
Tafsir Ibn Kathir on 17:110
Tafsir Ibn Kathir · 17:110
Allah Almighty commands the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him): "Say, 'Call upon Allah or call upon the Most Merciful. Whichever name you call, to Him belong the best names.'" This means it makes no difference whether you invoke Allah by the name "Allah" or by the name "Ar-Rahman" (the Most Merciful), for He possesses the most beautiful names, as indicated in Surah Al-Hashr (59:22-24), which enumerates His names and attributes including "He is Allah, besides Whom there is no deity; Knower of the unseen and the witnessed; He is the Most Merciful, Most Compassionate... To Him belong the best names." A report narrated by Mak'hul relates that a polytheist heard the Prophet (peace be upon him) calling during prostration, "O Most Merciful, O Most Compassionate," and remarked that the Prophet was calling upon two, not one. In response, Allah revealed this verse, clarifying the unity of the Divine names. This narration is also attributed to Ibn ‘Abbas and recorded by Ibn Jarir. Regarding the latter part of the verse, "And do not raise your voice in prayer nor be silent at it but seek a way in between," Imam Ahmad relates from Ibn ‘Abbas that this verse was revealed in Mecca when the Prophet prayed aloud with his companions. The polytheists mocked the Quran and its revealer upon hearing this loud recitation. Consequently, Allah instructed the Prophet neither to be loud so the disbelievers can hear and mock, nor too quiet among the companions so that they cannot hear and understand, but to find a moderate way between these extremes. This tradition is reported in Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim. Muhammad ibn Ishaq narrates from ‘Ikrimah via Ibn ‘Abbas that when the Prophet would recite aloud during prayer, some would distance themselves and not listen. One man would secretly listen, but when he feared being noticed, he would stop. When the Prophet lowered his voice, those wanting to hear could not catch the recitation. Thus, Allah revealed this verse directing the balance. Scholars such as Al-Hasan Al-Basri and Qatadah concur that the verse governs how the Quran is recited in prayer. Ibn Mas’ud relayed that it was not to be recited so quietly that only the person praying hears. Other reports mention that the verse was revealed concerning how to pray with neither ostentation nor shy concealment, as Ali ibn Abi Talhah reported from Ibn ‘Abbas. Another perspective is that the verse addresses the Prophet's prayer voice, neither shouting like the People of the Book who would call out loudly together nor whispering secretly in the hope others would not hear; the directive is to adopt a middle path, a mode taught by the Angel Gabriel. Concerning the subsequent verse, "And say: Praise be to Allah, Who has not taken a son and has no partner in sovereignty, nor has He any protector out of weakness; and exalt Him with [great] exaltation," Ibn Kathir explains that after affirming Allah possesses the most beautiful names and is beyond any defect, Allah declares His uniqueness by denying offspring or partners in dominion. He is the One, the Eternal Refuge, unbegotten and having no equal. "Nor does He have a protector out of weakness" means Allah is not humiliated, does not need a guardian, advisor, or helper; He alone creates, determines, and manages all affairs without associate. Mujahid states this indicates Allah makes no alliances or seeks aid from anyone. "And magnify Him with great magnification" commands to honor and exalt Allah supremely, distancing Him from what wrongful claimants say. Ibn Jarir narrates from Al-Qurazi that this verse addresses the rejection of certain beliefs held by Jews and Christians that Allah has a son, Arabs who associated partners with Allah in His dominion, and others like Sabians and Magians who believed without His allies, Allah would be humiliated. It is further related that the Prophet taught this verse to members of his household, both young and old, and some traditions call it the "Verse of Honor." One narration mentions that whenever this verse is recited in a household at night, neither theft nor calamity befalls them, though the authenticity of this is uncertain. Al-Hafiz Abu Ya'la reports a hadith from Abu Hurayrah, wherein the Prophet met a poor man and taught him this set of words: "I put my trust in the Ever-Living Who does not die, praise be to Allah Who has not taken a son, nor has He any partner in dominion, nor does He have a protector out of weakness, and magnify Him with great magnification." After reciting this, the man's condition improved. This hadith’s chain is weak and contains some criticism, though God knows best.
-
Sahih Muslim 4:163
Sahih Muslim · Book 4, Hadith 163 · Narrated by Ibn Abbas
Regarding the verse 'Do not make your prayer loud, nor make it silent, but seek a way in between,' Ibn Abbas said: When the Prophet (peace be upon him) was concealed in Mecca, if he prayed with his companions, he recited loudly. Upon hearing that, the disbelievers mocked the Quran, its sender, and the one who brought it. So Allah revealed this command forbidding loud or silent prayer, but to select a middle way between loudness and quietness, so that his companions could hear but disbelievers would not be distressed by it.
-
Al-Kafi 4:219
Al-Kafi · Book 4, Hadith 219
Ali (peace be upon him) often said: Whenever al-Taymi and al-Adawi came to the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him and his family) while he was reciting, “Indeed, We revealed it with reverence and emotion;” they said, “How tender you are at this surah!” The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him and his family) said: Due to what my eye saw and my heart grasped, and what the heart of this one will see after me. They asked: What did you see and what will he see? He wrote for them in the dust: “The angels and the Spirit descend therein by permission of their Lord with every matter.” He then asked: Is there anything remaining after Allah’s statement, “Every matter?” They said no. He asked: Do you know who the revealed one is at that time? They said: You, O Messenger of Allah. He said: Yes. Do you think the Night of Decree will be after me? They said yes. He said: Will the matter descend in it? They said yes. He said: To whom? They said we do not know. He grasped my head and said: Even if you do not know, know it is this after me. If they knew that night after the Messenger of Allah from terror that overwhelms them. — OR — I asked Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) whether the Imam should make those behind him hear the recitation, even if there are many. He said, "He should recite middlingly, saying 'Allah, blessed and exalted is He,' and not recite loudly nor whisper." — OR — Yunus said: I showed the book to him and he said it is authentic. Ibn Faddal said: The Commander of the Faithful (peace be upon him) ruled that if a man is injured in one of his eyes, it is measured by placing a white object tied to the injured eye and watching the vision of the sound eye, then the sound eye is covered and the injured is observed until its vision ends. The bloodmoney is given accordingly. The oath is also given by six people according to the amount of vision lost. If it is one-sixth of his eyesight, the injured swears alone and receives compensation; if one-third, he swears along with another man; if half, with two men; if two-thirds, with three men; if four-fifths, with four men; if all vision is lost, he swears with five men. The same applies to other wounds. If the injured has no sight, those who swear with him multiply. Oaths are doubled for less sight according to bracket: once for one-sixth, twice for one-third, and more according to this scale. The same ruling applies to hearing, but he is hit with something to discover the limit of hearing, then the measurement and oath are applied upon the perceived loss. If all hearing is lost and there is fear of injustice, the payment is withheld until the injured wakes from sleep and calls out; if he hears, the judge rules according to his discretion. If the defect is in the arm or thigh, it is measured by string: the sound leg is measured, then the injured leg, and the loss is determined. If the injury is on the shin or forearm, it is compared with the thigh or arm and the judge judges the extent of the thigh affected. Several of our companions narrated this from Sahl ibn Ziyad from Hasan ibn Zarif from Zarif ibn Nasih from a man called Abdullah ibn Ayyub who said: Abu Amr the doctor told me that he showed this book to Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him). Ali ibn Faddal narrated from Hasan ibn Jahm that he showed it to Abu al-Hasan al-Ridha (peace be upon him) and he told him to narrate it because it is authentic, then he mentioned the same.
Answers are generated and checked automatically; they may still be incomplete or imperfect. For religious rulings, consult a qualified scholar.
Ask your own question →