← Back to questions

Why do some Muslim pray Zuhur/Asr silently while Allah in [Al-Quran:17:110] says to pray in a moderate tone?

The practice of praying silently during the Zuhur and Asr prayers is indeed related to the guidance given in the Qur'an, specifically in Surah Al-Israa. The verse states: Say (unto mankind): Cry unto Allah, or cry unto the Beneficent, unto whichsoever ye cry (it is the same). His are the most beautiful names. And thou (Muhammad), be not loud-voiced in thy worship nor yet silent therein, but follow a way between. 17:110. This verse instructs the believers to find a balance in their prayer recitation—neither too loud nor too quiet.

Ibn Kathir explains that this verse was revealed in Mecca while the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was praying aloud, and the disbelievers mocked him and the Qur'an upon hearing it. Thus, Allah instructed him to avoid loud recitation that could attract mockery while also ensuring that the companions could hear him. The directive is about maintaining a moderate tone in worship (Tafsir Ibn Kathir).

Supporting this interpretation, Ibn Abbas narrated: Regarding the verse 'Do not make your prayer loud, nor make it silent, but seek a way in between,' Ibn Abbas said: When the Prophet (peace be upon him) was concealed in Mecca, if he prayed with his companions, he recited loudly. Upon hearing that, the disbelievers mocked the Quran, its sender, and the one who brought it. So Allah revealed this command forbidding loud or silent prayer, but to select a middle way between loudness and quietness, so that his companions could hear but disbelievers would not be distressed by it. Sahih Muslim 4:163SunniSAHIH.

Additionally, in Shia tradition, it is stated: I asked Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) whether the Imam should make those behind him hear the recitation, even if there are many. He said, 'He should recite middlingly, saying 'Allah, blessed and exalted is He,' and not recite loudly nor whisper. Al-Kafi 4:219Shia.

This balance is reflected in the practice of praying silently for the Zuhur and Asr prayers, allowing for a focus on the prayer without drawing attention or causing disturbance, thus following the guidance of maintaining moderation in worship as instructed in the Qur'an.

Sources

Answers are generated and checked automatically; they may still be incomplete or imperfect. For religious rulings, consult a qualified scholar.

Ask your own question →