← Back to questions

Why have supernatural miracles stopped?

The question of why supernatural miracles seem to have stopped is often explored through the lens of the signs and circumstances surrounding the various prophets sent by Allah. Each prophet was given miracles that were relevant to the prevailing circumstances of their respective communities. For example, Moses was sent with miracles such as his staff and the ability to part the sea, which were significant because magic was prevalent among his people. As noted in Al-Kafi, when Allah sent Moses, magic prevailed among his people, so He brought to them from Himself what was beyond their ability to do similar to it and invalidated their magic and established His proof over them Al-Kafi 1:20Shia. This highlights that the miracles served as a direct response to the needs and challenges faced by the people of that time.

In the case of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, he was sent when eloquent speech and poetry were the primary means of communication and persuasion. His miracle, the Qur'an, contained profound wisdom and admonition that invalidated the prevailing poetic expressions of the time. The approach of providing signs that resonate with the intellectual and cultural landscape of a society is consistent throughout the history of prophecy.

As for the cessation of supernatural miracles, scholars explain that the finality of prophethood with Muhammad ﷺ means that the primary guidance is now through the Qur'an and the teachings of the Prophet. Ibn Kathir explains that miracles were necessary for earlier prophets to validate their messages, but now the lasting miracle is the Qur'an itself, which invites reflection and reasoning rather than physical signs. The emphasis has shifted towards the intellect and the understanding of divine wisdom in the text. Thus, the focus on reasoning and the engagement with the Qur'an takes precedence over the need for further supernatural manifestations.

Sources

Answers are generated and checked automatically; they may still be incomplete or imperfect. For religious rulings, consult a qualified scholar.

Ask your own question →